| Date | Location | Result | |
| 02/27/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. - Connor Center | Thomas More 81, Thiel 43 | Box score |
| 2-24-09 | Grove City, Pa. - Grove City Coll. Arena | Thiel 65, Grove City 51 | Box score |
| 2-21-09 | Greenville, Pa. | Beeghly Gymnasium | Grove City 75, Thiel 64 | Box score |
| 2-18-09 | Beaver Falls, PA | Geneva 70, Thiel 46 | Box score |
| 02/14/09 | Greenville, Pa. | Beeghly Gymnasium | Thiel 86, Westminster 60 | Box score |
| 2-11-09 | Robert S. Carey Center | Saint Vincent 73, Thiel 64 | Box score |
| 2/7/09 | Washington, Pa. -- Henry Memorial Center | Wash. & Jeff. 71, Thiel 41 | Box score |
| 02/04/09 | Greenville, Pa. | Beeghly Gymnasium | Bethany 65, Thiel 61 | Box score |
| 01/30/09 | Greenville, Pa. | Beeghly Gymnasium | Chatham 86, Thiel 83 | Box score |
| 01/28/09 | Crestview Hills, Ky. - Connor Center | Thomas More 64, Thiel 31 | Box score |
| 01/24/09 | Marisa Fieldhouse; Waynesburg, Pa. | Thiel 57, Waynesburg 56 | Box score |
| 1-21-09 | Grove City, Pa. - Grove City Coll. Arena | Thiel 54, Grove City 44 | Box score |
| 01/17/09 | Greenville, Pa. | Beeghly Gymnasium | Thiel 74, Geneva 60 | Box score |
| 01/14/09 | New Wilmington, PA - Buzz Ridl Gymnasium | Westminster 76, Thiel 70 | Box score |
| 01/10/09 | Greenville, Pa. | Beeghly Gymnasium | Saint Vincent 65, Thiel 52 | Box score |
| 01/07/09 | Greenville, Pa. | Beeghly Gymnasium | Wash. & Jeff. 82, Thiel 46 | Box score |
| 1/3/09 | Bethany, WV - Hummel Field House | Thiel 82, Bethany 76 | Box score |
| 12/13/08 | Hiram, Ohio -- Price Gymnasium | Thiel 51, Hiram 37 | Box score |
| 12/08/08 | Cougar Den/Chatham University | Thiel 61, Chatham 41 | Box score |
| 12/06/08 | Greenville, Pa. | Beeghly Gymnasium | Thomas More 69, Thiel 46 | Box score |
| 12/03/08 | Greenville, Pa. | Beeghly Gymnasium | Waynesburg 66, Thiel 64 | Box score |
| 11/29/08 | Greenville, Pa. | Thiel 72, Kenyon 62 | Box score |
| 11-22-08 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Thiel 73, St. Mary of the Woods 54 | Box score |
| 11-21-08 | Bluffton, Ohio (Founders Hall) | Mt. Vernon Nazarene 77, Thiel 49 | Box score |
| 11-18-08 | Beeghly Gymnasium | Marietta 48, Thiel 47 | Box score |
| 11-15-08 | Pitt-Bradford | Thiel 58, Pitt-Bradford 52 | Box score |